Advice Night
Advice Night is where your messiest questions finally get an honest answer. Hosted by Stacy Jolley — the tough-love truth-teller who makes you laugh — every episode takes on real questions from real people: your love life, your in-laws, your terrible boss, that thing you're definitely overthinking.
Some weeks it's just you and Stacy. Other weeks she's joined by a guest — an expert who rolls up their sleeves to help her dig into your questions, or a brave soul in the hot seat working out a dilemma of their own, live. Either way, you get it straight: real advice, warm laughs, zero sugarcoating. Think Dear Abby, if she had a microphone and exactly zero chill.
Advice Night
He Doesn’t Want Kids and I Do. Now What? | Advice Night with Stacy Jolley and Cathy Yee
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
🎙️ What if you could skip the years of swiping and only meet people who are ready to start a family... like, now? Tonight I’m joined by Cathy Yee, the engineer-turned-matchmaker behind Procreate Match. ❤️💋
Cathy started her career as an engineer and holds two patents in medical devices from her time at Boston Scientific. Not exactly the résumé you’d expect from a matchmaker! But she looked at modern dating and decided it was the problem she wanted to solve. Now she runs Procreate Match, a matchmaking service for people who already know they want kids and are done spending years finding out whether the person across the table wants them too. And her very first match? They have a baby and another on the way! 👶
In this episode, Cathy explains the three ways Procreate Match brings families together, including co-parenting and “legacy” matches, and why she froze her own eggs. Then she answers your questions about being 38 and single with your biological clock ticking, whether matchmaking is really any different from the dating apps, and what to do when the man you love doesn’t want kids but you do. 💔
But first, I dig into the mystery mailbag for an Ask Stacy question from a listener whose mother-in-law reorganized her entire kitchen while house-sitting... and threw away her late grandmother’s handwritten recipe cards. Then she left a note saying “You’re welcome” with a smiley face. Oh, honey. 😳
💍 Find Cathy and Procreate Match
Learn more, apply, or book a call with a matchmaker: https://procreatematch.com
💬 Got a question for me? Submit it anonymously at https://www.advicenight.com 🤫 Shh... it’s our little secret. Come on, let’s get all up in your business! 😉
Find me on:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/advice.night/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61584648368838
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@advicenight
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AdviceNight
And as always, I seal every episode with a kiss. 💋
Hello, hello, my friends, and welcome back to the Advice Night Podcast. I am your host, Stacy Jolly, and I am so glad that you pulled up a chair with me tonight. As you know, Advice Night is all about you and your questions. Have you got something that you are dying to ask? Send it over to advice night.com and I will tackle it right here on the podcast. Whether you submit online or at one of the shows, you never have to put your name on it. Anonymously is sometimes the way to go. It can just be easier that way. Before we get to tonight's expert, let's dig into the mystery mailbag for tonight's Ask Stacy question. Prepare yourself. This one's a doozy. The reader asks, My in-laws watched our house and dog while we were on a week-long trip. When we got home, my mother-in-law had reorganized my entire kitchen. The spices are alphabetized, my pans are in a different cabinet, and she threw out a drawer of junk that included my late grandmother's handwritten recipe cards. She left a note that said, You're welcome with a smiley face. I found the cards in the trash, and a few are stained beyond saving. My husband says she meant well, and I should just say thank you. I haven't said a word yet, and I'm pretty sure I'm about to. Do I let it go or do I say something? I'm so sorry that you are going through this. It is awful to have your boundaries crossed and have your personal space invaded in that way. It feels like such a betrayal. So here is my advice. Since you're asking me, this is how I would handle it. The first thing is in all things, we are happier in life, and we should always try to go through life presuming positive intent. Now, I don't know your mother-in-law, but my good friend Dave Anderson used that phrase all the time. Presume with positive intent. So trying your hardest to look at this, that your mother-in-law truly was trying to help you. It's hard to do. It doesn't take away the hurt that it caused or the feeling of betrayal about your boundaries, but try to think of it that she was trying to do something to help you. And it helps frame it in a way that gets you closer towards grace and forgiveness of the situation. The second thing is, I would think real hard about ever having this woman dog sit her house sit for you again, because the next thing she might try to reorganize is your underwear drawer. And this woman clearly doesn't understand boundaries. So be careful because left alone in your spaces, you don't know what she will do next. Your kitchen may be the least of it. So take caution. As far as whether or not you should say something, just know that normally the purpose of saying something to someone is to help change the behavior. You are not going to change this woman. If you happen to be really close to her, then certainly saying something could if you're very close and you say, I know that you were trying to be very helpful and I appreciate the effort, I really would ask that the next time you not rearrange anything, that's perfectly acceptable to say it. But if you aren't particularly close to this woman and you don't have a tender relationship with her, saying something about it is not going to change her. She is not going to learn boundaries from this. So probably saying nothing is probably for the best. If you have to say something, and I understand if you do, it's probably best to say I appreciate that you were trying to help. I did end up moving my pots and pans back just because I'm comfortable cooking where they were, and I did manage to get my grandma's recipe cards that were in the trash. I did manage to find most of them and salvage most of them. But I do appreciate the effort that you were trying to help me. That's that presuming positive intent. And if in the future you feel like you want to help in some way, if you could just ask me first, please, I would appreciate it. The bigger issue you have is saying to your husband in private, please just validate my feelings that she invaded my space. Because you want your husband to have your back and understand why you feel betrayed and why it feels icky to you that his mother came in and messed with your space. Overall, I would say let it go. And I know it's hard, but that's my advice. Okay, let's get to tonight's expert. Let me tell you about Kathy Yee. Kathy started her career as an engineer, and she holds two patents in medical devices from her time at Boston Scientific. So picture someone who spent years building things where the answer is either right or it isn't. Not exactly the resume that you would expect from a matchmaker. But think again. She looked at modern dating and decided that it was the problem that she wanted to solve. Now she runs Procreate Match, which is matchmaking for people who already know they are ready to start a family. Like now. And they are done spending years swiping to find out whether the person across the table wants one too. She brings an engineer's mind to it, but her approach is compassionate and very human. And she works with people on the timelines, the nerves, and the big question of how and with whom to build a family. Because at the end of the day, a lot of people feel they are running out of time to find their person and they're tired of doing it alone. And now we are so lucky to have her here to share her wisdom with us and answer your questions. Kathy Yee, welcome to Advice Night. Hi, Stacy. Thank you. Thanks for having me on here. Yes, thank you so much for making time for us. Our viewers are in for a treat, I know. So before we tackle the three viewer questions that I have pulled, I have sort of an intro question for you. Can you tell me about either the first match that you made or a moment with a client that made you think this is exactly why I am doing this?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, definitely. So the first match that I made was actually a friend who was looking to have kids and it started as a very personal journey. And yeah, she, you know, couldn't find someone. She was in the Midwest, and um it was kind of in a new area for her. So she was having trouble kind of like making friends, meeting guys. Um, and then I happened to know someone too, so this all started very local. Um and he yeah, was looking for like a really nice woman, and he wasn't on the apps, and he was like very kind of innocent, like very good hearted, and I set them up and put them together. Um, and yeah, now they have a baby. Um and a second baby on the way. But yeah, these human connections really matter, and I think you know, with the digital age and the AI age, it can be hard to kind of meet people the old-fashioned way, like through community and other people. So yeah, that really kind of um inspires me. Yeah, I believe it.
SPEAKER_00And one of the questions is actually about the apps. So this is gonna be a good lead-in to the I can't remember if it's the second or third question. So we're gonna get back to the apps. So this is great. Okay, so as a kind of follow-up to this, I read that Procreate Match offers three sort of different or or not different options, but it sort of fits three different needs. And the first one seems pretty straightforward. Partner match for people who want a lasting relationship and parenthood. And I mean, that one seems pretty straightforward. I mean, someone is like, you know, I am ready to settle down, get married, have a baby, or you know, be in a committed partnership and have a baby. But the second two I think need a little bit more explanation. So the next one that I read about was co-parent match for people who want to raise a child together without being a couple. And then the third, legacy match for people who want to build a legacy through their children. And I was like, I'm not even sure what this means, Kathy. Can you tell me more? So could you tell us a little more about both option two and option three?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, definitely. Um, and yeah, these are the two that people have the most questions on. Um, they are the most non-traditional. Um, the first one, just very briefly, um, is traditional, you know, romance and marriage. Um, so what most people out there are looking for and what most of our clients um either sign up for or prefer to as their you know first choice. Um but then yeah, there's a lot of people nowadays who are in unconventional family arrangements. Um, you know, you've seen the show modern family possibly. Um but yeah, co-parent matching is for people who are single, um and they don't necessarily want to get married or they're not very optimistic about their um, you know, um possibility of finding the one in a short amount of time and time to have a kid with. Uh so yeah, we have some people coming to us who are looking for a co-parent, and even um, you know, women who are looking for other women, and they're not um, you know, they're straight in terms of their orientation, um, but they're looking to co-parent with someone and have a kid sooner uh rather than kind of waiting for the one. So this way they can have kids on the timeline they need and wait for later to, you know, find their love partner. Yeah. Okay. And Legacy Match, tell us about that. Yeah. So Legacy Match is also more unconventional, um, but it's for those who kind of have the um success and resources. Um, you know, they're accomplished in their career, um, they tend to be more ambitious. Um, and they're looking to kind of, it's a variation of co-parent match, but where they're looking for someone who's more nurturing and who doesn't necessarily have, you know, the financial resources to have kids, since you know, kids, everyone says kids are expensive these days. Um, and yeah. Um, so yeah, it's more of a partnership where generally um one person is um can be older or more successful, and they're looking for someone who's more nurturing, um, who can be younger in either direction, um, you know, whether it's an older man or an older woman. Um, yeah.
SPEAKER_00So I see. So they want to have a child with that person, but it tends to maybe be, am I understanding correctly, more of a May-December relationship?
SPEAKER_01Kind of. Um, yeah, they can choose to, you know, stay in touch and you know, be friends. Oh, I see. Okay. Yeah, yeah. Um, yeah, they can choose to live together, they can choose to not, it's different from surrogacy, where it's um kind of, you know, one person, the woman carries the child and then they kind of part ways afterwards. This is where they continue um being involved to some degree, um, definitely financially, um, but it can be poor too.
SPEAKER_00Got it, got it. So if I were the financially independent person and I didn't have a child, but I wanted a child, I might, I might, the child might live with me, but I might stay in touch with like the the child's father might be sort of in their life, but live with me.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. It really um depends on the couple involved. Um, each situation is unique. Um, but yeah, there's like some, you know, financial support. Um, and the reason why someone may choose this is because um it's a type of you know, man or woman who's more responsible. You know, they're not going to just knock someone up to to have a kid. And yeah, they want their child to be successful and happy. So um, yeah, they have the financial means to kind of uh make for this arrangement. And sometimes they have different standards in terms of um like attraction and looks, like they may be looking for someone who's like very young and attractive or someone who's like very caring and you know, more nurturing and um yeah, has more, I guess, family connections. Sure, sure.
SPEAKER_00Very interesting. Very interesting. Now I'm curious. Let's say the roles were reversed and the person of means was an older man. Does the child typically to your knowledge live with the older man or with the younger woman who was, you know, the birth mother of the child? Do you know?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, good question. Um, and usually it is the child um spends more time with the more nurturing woman in this situation. Um and yeah, the it's not like you know, the father has no rights to visit the child, like what would happen in a divorce sometimes. Um, but yeah, it's usually a pretty friendly arrangement. Um, it's no emotional baggage that sometimes happens with divorce. So it's kind of like a fresh, you know, arrangement.
SPEAKER_00But then the older gentleman has an heir to their fortune of whatever sort. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01They have a child, like maybe, yeah, maybe want a child, but maybe you know, they work a lot or they don't, you know, emotionally have the resources to be um like a good father emotionally or an equal partner.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yes, yes, I yes, very interesting. Oh, Kathy, this is so interesting. Okay. So fun. So, uh, this is all great. So shall we help some viewers? Yeah, yeah. Okay, let's get all up in their business. This first one is about the timing of having a baby. Okay, so the viewer asks, I am 38 and single, and I have always thought that I would have kids by now, and I am starting to panic. I don't want to settle, but I'm scared that if I hold out for the one, I will run out of time to have a family at all. The biological clock is ticking. What do I do? So I'm sure that you experience this in your clientele. What is your advice for this person? Yeah, definitely.
SPEAKER_01And the good news is, you know, nowadays um we as women have a lot more options than ever before. Um, and you know, scientific uh advancements have really helped too. So I would say a few things. Um, one, you know, you can look into freezing your eggs if you would like to, you know, hold out for the one. Um, two, you could try something like matchmaking, some of them like ours, like if you sign up for um, you know, the actual matchmaking, we have uh timeline guarantees. We'll we'll introduce you, yeah. Um who also want to have kids sooner rather than later. Um and yeah, with Procreate Match, yeah, the whole focus is for people who want to have kids soon. So um, if you were looking into something like us, it would be um yeah, looking into the romantic option and then kind of as a backup, um, sometimes people choose like the co-parenting match as um the backup if they're like, oh my gosh, my clock.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yes, I've never thought about this like this. So what what made you think of this idea? I mean, it seems so it seems like you're cutting out a big chunk of the a big chunk of the problem for a lot of people, like dancing around the issue for this type of a person. She how old did she say she was? She's 38. She is feeling this pressure to have a baby. She's ready. But going, you know, a traditional route, meeting someone, you know, offline or even online. You go through a long dance of getting to know the person and do they even want kids and all of that. What gave you this idea to have this sort of baby focused matchmaking?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, thanks for asking that. Um, a lot of people, you know, they do uh like the idea, and it does resonate a lot because um we're in the society where for some reason it's um taboo to talk about wanting kids early, whereas historically, traditionally, you know, it was assumed, like obviously, you know, you're gonna date to get married and have kids. Like, why else would you be dating? Um, but yeah, it does seem to be the case where, you know, if someone brings it up on the first day or early, the other person gets, you know, freaked out for some reason. So yeah, we cut out that awkwardness. Um, you know, we can't entirely fight um how the society is now in terms of you know how people react in modern culture, but we can bring people who are already ready. You know, the name of the company is procreate match, so no one is surprised. Um, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Wow. And and so was there a moment where you're like, wait a minute, this could work. I mean, what do you recall the moment when it sort of clicked for you? I know you're an engineer, so you're a problem solver by nature. But do you recall the moment when the idea came to you?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um, so I actually, you know, faced this too, where, you know, I was like, oh my gosh, people are telling me it's better to have kids before 35. Um, and I want to have kids. Um, so I froze my eggs. Um and I did so in Greece, actually. Oh. Um yeah. And I met other people who are freezing their eggs, and um, I met men who are freezing their sperm.
unknownOh.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, you know, like sometimes people have can have an idea where men, you know, don't want to have kids as much, or that it's gonna be mostly women. Um, but there are men freezing their sperm and who, you know, really want to start a family, and um, you know, men have a different type of biological clock, too. I think a lot of people don't realize. Um, so it's better for men to have kids before 40. Um I didn't know that. Yeah. Yeah. The CDC says um for sperm health and you know, for the future child's health, it's generally better for men to have kids before 40.
SPEAKER_00Um interesting, very interesting. Okay, question number two. This one is about dating burnout. Okay, so the viewer asks I have been on dating apps. Here's the dating apps question. I have been on dating apps for three years and I am exhausted. I will just say dating apps. Are trash. Is matchmaking actually different, or is it just a more expensive version of the same thing?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, good question. Matchmaking, um, I think it's having more of an appearance nowadays, but it used to be something that was more in like Indian and Jewish cultures. Um but yeah, so with matchmaking, um generally it's typically the opposite of apps in Tinder. There's no swiping involved. Um so it really brings back that human community aspect um that we had throughout, you know, throughout the ages. Um so instead of you know meeting someone in college or school or high school or church, um, we the matchmakers are kind of the community. Um and yeah, it is different. Um it is more expensive. You know, the apps will charge, you know, they're free or $10 a month. Um, but you know, we really bring people together and you know, finding the right partner and having kids and starting family is arguably more important than um which car you buy or which house you buy. So it is, you know, we do bring that level of um seriousness uh to the to the equation.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00Most definitely. And are you geographically everywhere in the United States? Are you in multiple countries? Like, I mean, I live in Omaha, Nebraska. Now I'm happily married, so I I'm not looking for making matches, but I can imagine if I have listeners here in Omaha, or I know I have people who are listening all around the country. I know I have people who listen in other countries. So how do I know if I sign up that you have people, other people in my city that you would be able to match with me?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, that's a good question. Yeah, there are definitely, you know, the major cities we uh serve a lot and then small towns. Um so we have people who apply everywhere, and you know, have members and clients all across the US. Um, we also partner with other matchmakers. So we join a couple of alliances. Um, and yeah, so we do referrals and you know, we work with a lot of matchmakers who, you know, we're the only ones who focus on people who want to have kids soon. Um, so yeah, all the other matchmakers, you know, they have a variety of clients. Um, and yeah, we we partner with them um so that we can reach people in the small towns and on the outskirts. Um and our focus is the US, but we do have applicants um from other countries and and members in other countries. Um, and yeah, we're looking to partner more internationally, but it is a more US-focused market right now.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Oh, that's awesome. Okay, so shifting gears a little bit for question three. This viewer asks, I have been dating an amazing man for a year. He is funny, kind, stable, everything I wanted. But he told me early on that he doesn't want kids, and I do. I keep telling myself that he will change his mind, and I feel like an idiot for hoping. What do I do? Oh what advice do you have for this poor woman, Kathy?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I guess first of all, you know, I feel for her. Um it is a tough situation to be, you know, attached, um, you know, emotionally attached to someone. You really like them, they're a good person, um, but they just simply, you know, don't want kids. Um I would say, you know, to start dating, um, you know, I would say if she truly wants kids, um, you know, it may be difficult, but the right thing to do would be to um, you know, end the relationship and start dating and looking for someone who does want kids. Um, because that type of thing, yes, it has happened that people change their minds. Um, but also I would say a larger amount of people don't change their minds. Um, and you know, if you're at an age where having kids is better uh sooner, you know, like uh you're approaching your biological clock. Um, so to speak, it's better to just end the relationship. Otherwise, you know, resentment will build, anxiety will build, and um, yeah, it's better to look elsewhere. You can still, you know, um be friends if that works for you, or you know, give it some time and we can meet in the future as friends. Um, because you know, we're all still humans in the end, you know, a lot of the advice about um cutting people off is very strict. But yeah, I would say, you know, focus, focus on having finding someone who wants kids too.
SPEAKER_00I totally agree. That's the same advice that I would give to this woman. I think that, you know, this is something this is something so fundamental for people that I don't think that this is something that she should compromise on if it is important to her. It's one thing to compromise on, you know, if you live downtown or in the suburbs, or you know, if you if you what city you live in, or those types of things. Having a child is so fundamental and so um primal to for for not and not everybody wants one, and that's totally fine too. He's completely valid in his not wanting one, but I think you're absolutely right, Kathy. I think if she does not make that choice for herself, I think the bitterness that she feels will end up ending this relationship in the long run. And then it will be too late. And then she'll have the heartache that I should have done it sooner when I still was able to have a child. Yeah, yeah. So better to do it now while she can.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And biology, you can't control it, you know. You can't um, yeah, you don't exactly know when at what age, at what time your biological clock will be up. Um, so yeah, it's definitely uh better to um get it over with sooner. Exactly.
SPEAKER_00It'll be hard and it'll be heartbreaking, but he may seem like the perfect man, but he's not the perfect fit for her. So okay. This is the fourth question that I always ask my guests, and that is what is a piece of advice that you would like to share that I have not asked you about tonight that you think our viewers should know.
SPEAKER_01Hmm, thank you. Yes, advice night.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01Um I would say, you know, that if you are tired of um the ghosting and the you know, first dates, or even even um, you know, not being able to go on dates uh or go on dates with the right people, if you're tired of all that headache, I would say that you don't necessarily have to like sign up for matchmaking right away, but I would say at least talk to a matchmaker and kind of learn about it, what they're about, what it's all about. Um, because it is really about bringing back the community and human side of um dating and relationships. Um so yeah.
SPEAKER_00I love that. I just feel like we need people more than ever. Mm-hmm. Yes. I mean, tech is so great. I mean, you worked at Boston Scientific for heaven's sake. You know how great tech is. Yeah. But it has robbed us of so much of the community and person-to-person interaction that we all just need so badly. Yes. Oh my. And tech's great because it means I got to meet you today. But by this tech, it means that I actually get to have a conversation with you. And that's the fun part is actually talking to someone. So yes, that's awesome advice. Kathy, where can people find you if they want to learn more about Procreate Match or any of your other work?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, um, so we're not active on social media, so I know that's a typical channel that people may advise, but um, yeah, the easiest way to go to our website um and yeah, learn more, read about us. Um, you know, you can go straight into applying if you're interested, or yeah, book a call with a matchmaker and yeah, you can learn more.
SPEAKER_00Okay. And is a consultation with a matchmaker, is that like a free first call? I I don't know how this works exactly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, good question. So we are elite matchmaking, but we do have a special rate of um it's currently $25 for a call. So something that's easy, but um, where we don't get no shows and we make sure people are serious. Yeah. There you go.
SPEAKER_00There you go. Okay. We will put a link to your website in the show notes so that our viewers can find you. Happy ye, thank you so much for joining me on Advice Night tonight. This was so educational and really fun talking to you. I really appreciate your time.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, thanks, Stacey. It was lovely being here. And yeah, you're such a fun and positive interviewer. I appreciate it.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. And to all of the viewers and listeners, I have two jobs for you. Number one, hit the follow button so that you can be notified when new episodes come out. And number two, head to advice night.com and submit your question. Remember, shh, it can be anonymous so that I can answer it here or on my socials. Look for Advice Night on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and TikTok, and send those questions so that I can get all up in your business. Okay, Kathy, I seal every episode with a kiss. I hope that you will join me. I will count us down in three, two, one. Bye bye. Hi, this is Stacy with Advice Night, and this is your reminder that I am not a doctor, a lawyer, or a therapist. Advice Night is for entertainment purposes only, and I certainly hope that you were entertained.