Advice Night
Advice Night is where your messiest questions finally get an honest answer. Hosted by Stacy Jolley — the tough-love truth-teller who makes you laugh — every episode takes on real questions from real people: your love life, your in-laws, your terrible boss, that thing you're definitely overthinking.
Some weeks it's just you and Stacy. Other weeks she's joined by a guest — an expert who rolls up their sleeves to help her dig into your questions, or a brave soul in the hot seat working out a dilemma of their own, live. Either way, you get it straight: real advice, warm laughs, zero sugarcoating. Think Dear Abby, if she had a microphone and exactly zero chill.
Advice Night
Two Dads, No Roadmap: Our Foster Adoption Story | Advice Night with Stacy Jolley and Dr. Lane Igoudin
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Okay, friends, grab your tissues, because this one got me. 🥹 Tonight I'm joined by Dr. Lane Igoudin, and we're getting ALL up in the business of foster adoption, being two dads, and coming out to your parents.
Let me tell you about Lane. He and his husband John became dads through foster adoption back when there was NO roadmap for out gay men building families this way. Talk about major build-the-plane-while-flying-it vibes! Their daughters came to them as a newborn and a one-year-old, and it took YEARS in the court system before those girls were legally theirs (even though they were theirs in their hearts from day one). Lane has shared his story on NBC, NPR, and so many stages, and he's changing how people think about what family can look like.
I asked Lane the questions you all sent in. We talked about the real differences between domestic, international, and foster adoption (this one came from one of my best friends!), why the reunification debate gets so heated online, and what it was like raising two little girls through Prop 8, DOMA, and years of legal limbo. Then I asked him to share some comfort with a sweet viewer who's nervous about coming out to their parents... and his answer had me in actual tears. Good luck, kiddo. We're rooting for you. 💛
Stick around to the end for the relationship advice Lane swears holds a family together. He and John just celebrated 29 years, so trust me, you want to hear it!
⏱️ Chapters
00:00 Meet Dr. Lane Igoudin
01:43 Lane's favorite parts of being a dad
03:22 Domestic vs. international vs. foster adoption
07:40 "The goal of foster care is reunification": let's talk about it
12:24 How long until the girls were legally theirs
14:22 Parenting as two dads: Prop 8, DOMA & legal limbo
18:17 Being a visible family & finding your village
21:48 How to come out to your parents
26:15 Lane's advice for future foster parents & couples
28:42 Where to find Lane & his book
📖 Grab Lane's book, A Family, Maybe (2nd edition!)
It reads like a novel, but every bit of it really happened. You can find it on Amazon, Bookshop.org, and Barnes & Noble, or head to his website and he'll sign a copy and mail it to you!
🌐 laneigoudin.com
📱 Follow Lane on Instagram: @laneigoudin | Facebook: Lane Igoudin
💬 Now I've got two jobs for you:
1️⃣ Hit that subscribe button so you know when new episodes drop!
2️⃣ Head over to advicenight.com and submit YOUR questions. Shh... it's anonymous! 🤫 I'll answer them on the show or on my socials so I can get all up in your business.
Find me on:
Instagram: @advice.night YouTube: @AdviceNight Facebook: Advice Night TikTok:@advicenight
💋 Until next time… send me your questions so I can get all up in your business!
#FosterAdoption #Adoption #LGBTQParents #GayDads #ComingOut #FosterCare #ParentingAdvice #AdviceNight #TwoDads #ModernFamily
Hello, hello, my friends, and welcome back to the Advice Night Podcast. I'm your host, Stacey Jolly, and I am thrilled that you are here with me tonight. As you know, Advice Night is about you and your questions. Have you sent me a question yet? If not, send me your questions at advice night.com and I will tackle them right here on the podcast. As always, whether you submit online or at one of my live shows, you do not have to share your name because sometimes it is just easier to ask shh anonymously. Before we get to today's expert, I am going to answer a random viewer question that came in. Okay, here we go. My mom just isn't like a mom to me at all. She is selfish about everything and expects me to drop everything about my life, even though I work full-time and am a single mom to do stuff for her. She is physically and mentally capable of caring for herself, but it's just that everything is about her. Holidays, my kids' birthday parties, even regular dinners usually end up getting ruined with her screaming at me for one reason or another. I'm more sad than mad. I'm a grown-up woman, but I still wish that I could turn to her and have her help and comfort me. I just wish she was more like a mom. How can I make her act like a mom? Oh, this is just a heartbreaker. I am so, so sorry that you are dealing with this. Yes, love and care from a mom is something that we all want and that we all need and that we all deserve, and you do deserve that. And I am sorry that your mom is not giving it to you. And I'm also sorry to say that there is not anything that you can do to change it. You did not make your mom this way, and you can't change her into a different kind of mom. And the hardest part of dealing with situations like this is letting go of what should have been. Your mom should be a better mom to you, but she's not. And it's only when you let go of that expectation that you will be able to move on in peace. And I don't want you to confuse that I am saying that this is easy or that this is fair, because it's not, but it's a fact that the only way to move on is to let go of the expectation that she can be something that she's not. And I don't know why she isn't capable of doing it. Maybe it's a trauma from her past, maybe she wasn't taught, maybe she had a crappy role model. But I do know that you have an opportunity to stop history from repeating itself. You know how bad this feels, and you have the ability to be to your kids what you wish your mom were to you. So that is where I would focus my energy if I were you. And then the second thing I would do is I would see if you can find another older woman that you can incorporate into your life, like maybe an aunt, an elderly neighbor. And if you really don't have a single older woman in your life, you could even volunteer at a senior center. And I am being completely honest when I say that. And we need older women in our lives to help us navigate the tricky times and the complicated feelings of being a mom and being a woman. And we need their senior wisdom for perspective in our lives. So that would be my advice. And then the last thing I'd say about this is I am not a big fan of no contact. I know it's needed in some extreme circumstances, but in this case, although I probably wouldn't go no contact, I would certainly go low contact, and there is no way I would have my mom at my kids' birthday parties anymore if it ends up with her screaming at me, because I'm not gonna let her ruin my kids' experiences and create a toxic environment for them. I'll put up with it myself, but I would go lower contact just to protect my own heart. I hope that that was helpful. Okay, all right, let's get to this episode's expert. Let me tell you a little bit about Dr. Lane Aguden. Lane became a dad through foster adoption, and he did it as part of the first generation of out gay men building families like that. So there was no roadmap, no here's how you do this guidebook sitting around. He and his husband John had to figure it out as they went. And this definitely gives me major build the plane while flying it vibes. That journey turned into something bigger than just his own family's story. And Lane started speaking about it everywhere: NBC, NPR, podcasts, live shows. More than anything, he knows that his story goes beyond his family. It could be the lifeline that someone needs when they are fighting to have a family of their own. And he's actually shifting how people think about foster adoption, parenting, and what family can look like. Lane is also a professor of English and linguistics, but what really lights him up is the real messy parts of life and just being a dad, which was always the goal to begin with. And now he is here to share all of his wisdom with us here at Advice Night and answer your questions. Dr. Lane Aguden, welcome to Advice Night.
SPEAKER_02Glad to be here. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00Yes, thank you so much for being here and sharing your hard won wisdom with us tonight. So before we tackle the three viewer questions that I have pulled, I have an intro question to ask you first. So, what are your top two or three favorite parts about being a dad?
SPEAKER_02That's a good question. That's a really good question. Um well, one of them would be to um just to spend time with my kids at home, honestly, not like some you know, vacations or or holidays. It's just like, you know, sometimes I just catch myself sitting and just looking at them and like I can't believe this has actually happened. It happened to me. So um that's that's that that that would be one. And another one I would say is um learning from them. Um learning from them. I I in a way I think my teacher, my kids have been my biggest teachers in life. And so uh, if it hadn't been for that experience, I would have been a very different person. So I feel like they've changed in many ways. So and I and I learned a lot from them.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And how old are your kids now?
SPEAKER_02Our daughters are now 20 and 22.
SPEAKER_00Ah, so now they are full-grown adults, and you have so much to learn from them now, especially.
SPEAKER_02Right, but the story goes all the way to the beginning of our family when then they were uh one was a newborn and her sister was one.
SPEAKER_00Wow. Wow. I can't wait to hear more about the story. And I I think this first question is going to really give you an opportunity to tell us that story. So let's get all up in the business of these advice night viewers. And this is the first question. It's sort of a general adoption question. And uh one of my best friends built her family with adoption too. And so she had submitted this question. And uh when I talked to her, she said, we had suffered many, we had suffered multiple miscarriages and were thinking of starting our adoption journey. And the biggest question that was on their mind was, what was the difference between domestic, international, and foster care adoption? And what were the pros and cons of doing those different types of adoption and why did you choose what you chose?
SPEAKER_02Right, those are the same paths that were already available to us, you know, 20 years ago. So I'm I'm I'm quite familiar with all three of them because I but we do we also have friends who've gone other adoption routes as well. Um the difference between the international and uh domestic or private adoption, as it is known, on one hand and foster adoption on the other, is that once um the arrangement is finalized, you know, then you know, if you're out of the country through the agency and you bring your child back, or domestically, if um you've been matched with uh with a woman who is willing to to um to give you her child to raise. Um basically once that's been finalized, um, and I just with a little caveat, uh, with uh with private adoption, uh each state sets its own um number of days within which the woman can change her mind, but but ultimately it's it's usually not long. We're talking about like in California, I think it's 30 days. After that, the children are yours. The children are yours. There's nothing that can take them back or out of your family, um, you know, back to the biological families that they came from. With a foster adoption, you are in a way competing with the biological family all the way until the termination of parental rights of the birth family. And um, and that that process may take not um days or weeks or a month, but sometimes months, and um, as you know, as you learn from my story, our story, years. So, in that sense, there's a great sense of uncertainty about the outcome, and things may change, and in many ways, um the way the process goes um really depends not so much on you um but on the on the judge, the court system, and the biological parents. So kind of your the the future of your family is subject to uh what happens in the children's courtroom. Um that said, the other difference between between like private and international on one hand and the and the foster adoption on the other, is that foster adoption serve serves a much bigger need, I would say. It's you know, by by we had all these routes available to us, as well as surrogacy. You know, both my my husband and I are you know full-time working adults. Um, you know, we could have afforded, let's just be clear, surrogacy. But that's not what we want. We it's not like we just wanted to expand our family. We wanted to give a home to one or two children in this community. We live in Los Angeles County, in this community that needed a home. And there was a great need at that time and still is. So when you do this, even though this, you know, uh there might be higher obstacles and might be more difficult at times, ultimately it's a much more, I don't want to say powerful experiment, but that's but I think it changes much more than just expanding your family, adding HL uh to your family. And that's how it was with us too.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. And so can you tell us? I will, I will let me ask a follow-on question, and then maybe you can tell us a little bit more about what happened in your situation. I read, I've read a few online posts about I read a woman who was saying, we are interested in wanting to adopt from foster care. And some of the comments, some of the respondents to this woman absolutely flamed her, uh saying the goal of foster is reunification, and really just oh, I I just felt terrible for this woman that they they treated her quite cruelly. And she was asking in very good faith, I felt, for information about this. Can you talk us through the thought process there, that argument, what you may have faced in that situation?
SPEAKER_02Um, yes, and actually adding back to what I said previously about the differences between different types of adoption, I should say exactly because you are helping the society by providing a a um a uh forever permanent home for a child, the state actually helps you too. You know, I know it is a consideration uh for a lot of people. Will I be able to financially manage this? So the state, and I'm speaking for the state of California again here, but I'm sure it's I think the process is very similar in every state, will provide you, the adoptive parent who is adopting from foster care, with financial support during and after the process, and will also provide your children with um insurance and and some other perks, um, you know, all the way into their, you know, uh up until they reach adulthood and sometimes even after that in some ways. So there is, you know, you're not entirely alone in on on that on the material side of things. Um and I wouldn't say it makes up to uh it makes up for for um for the uh possible headache you might, you know, heartache you might go through, but it it it definitely helps. It definitely helps. Um so to to go back to the process, so the uh the federal law is actually pretty clear. Um it says that when if when a child is removed from from a home and there are certain criteria uh uh for the social services to do so, neglect, abuse, and so on and so forth, um they, you know, unless the child goes back very very quickly, you know, within I forget, you know, maybe a day or two or three, uh basically if the child if the child has to come under the under the um children's court custody, under you know, go into the state custody, the state has to provide what's called a concurrent planning, two tracks. Track A would be returning the child back to the biological family, to the natural parents. Um, and track two would be what will happen if that is not going to happen. Like what would be the alternative track? Where will the child go? Will the child uh go um into foster home uh for now, long-term, long-term foster foster home to a relative or to a foster home which is willing or interested in potentially adopting this? So what's the what's the track to? And I would say that much as all of us, myself included, would want the child to be raised by their biological parents, of course. You know, that's you know, parents, children, you know, of course, you know, they should be together. In the situations where it doesn't happen, you know, uh the track, you know, the the second track should really take precedence. What we encountered is that kind of what you heard in that online post, that in the situation that we were in, um, that the entire interest of the court centered on reunifying the children with their birth parents, even though it was very clear that neither of them was capable of taking care of their children, you know, capable of taking care of themselves, and specifically the birth mother. And um, they needed to be helped at a large scale just to be able to build up their own lives before you will trust them uh with a child. Um, so despite all of this, the the court continued to try and try and try to to to to return the children to um to their birth family. And that's that's and and I and I and I describe, you know, in when I speak and also my book uh what exactly happened.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes. And how old were your daughters when they finally, when it was finally resolved and they permanently became yours? I know they were yours in your heart from day one.
SPEAKER_02They were ours in our heart from like the moment the cross.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. There's no question about that. Yeah. When did they legally become yours? How old were they then?
SPEAKER_02Um legally, I would say by age of three or four three and four.
SPEAKER_00Oh, the longest three and four years of your life.
SPEAKER_02Yes. However, the older one was already in foster care when we took her out of it and brought we kind of took her over her foster parents. So she was not, she wasn't with her um birth parents. She hadn't been actually with her birth parents at that point for five months when we met her. So she was 12 months old when we met her, and uh she was a you know teeny weeny little little baby crawling, uh still crawling, you know, so she crawled until she was 17 months. Um, but she was absolutely uh but the thing is, all that said, she had already been living in an emergency foster home for five months.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_02So that's where we took her out of. Our younger daughter, her sister, was a newborn, and she was brought straight to our home from the hospital. So she never actually lived with her birth parents. She she would see her birth mother and her birth father um at visits, um, but without any understanding who they were, because you know, uh she would be if you've if you if you if you were if you are if you're a small child and you see an adult that is unfamiliar to you for an hour or two a week, it doesn't put much of an impression.
SPEAKER_00You and John were the parents to her 24-7.
SPEAKER_0224-7. Absolutely. Uh week after week, month after month, year after year.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Absolutely. Okay, so as I was talking, can we go to question two?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so this question was also from my girlfriend. She said, I have an additional question. She said, let's talk about what it's like to parent as two dads. She said, Have you ever encountered situations where you have received any pushback about that or that your children have received any pushback about that? Now you've mentioned you live in California. Um, but I'm just curious if you either legally, when you were first in that adoption process, or now societal, societally societally or legally.
SPEAKER_02Um at the time that went into the process, this was before uh marriage equality. And so we were in a very weird legal situation where we were two unrelated adults raising two related children. And that's how it was all the way until we even even when we finalized adoptions, we were still we couldn't get married. We couldn't get married. So we were two um single individuals. And towards the end of us, in 2008, California uh allowed same-sex marriage, and we got married, but then um five months after that decision came down in the fall of 2008, um, proposition 8 was passed by California voters, which outlawed same-sex marriage again. And so after that, we and 18,000 other California uh California same-sex couples ended up in a situation when we were in a limbo. Uh we were married in the state of California. Some states recognized it, other states didn't, and the federal government did not recognize it because it had the Defense of Marriage Act on the books. So from 2008 till 2015, from until 2015, we were in this weird legal situation where we had to file um different types of taxes, you know, married in California, uh single, you know, for the federal. We had all kinds of you know, weird, like legally, it was a very, very difficult time. Um and I like to talk about, even though that sounds like a long time ago, although 2015 isn't wasn't all that long ago, but we we can be back in that landscape. know with one dis just with one decision of the Supreme Court that will leave it up to the states will be back to back to where we were 25 years ago. So um and we were involved with the movement at that time, you know, in many different ways. We uh of course you know signed petitions, uh marched, you know, and and put, you know, I remember pushing the double stroller and pride parades, you know, went to the meetings, volunteered, voted, and even testified all the way to the actually we testified before the Judiciary Committee of the U.S. Senate to try to over overrule um Defense of Marriage Act in 2012, but it didn't happen then. It would happen later. So that was the legal part. As far as socially, you have to realize that when you see a black man, that's my husband, and myself uh walking together, you might assume so has a kind of turn to check what's going on, right? In our case, they would assume correctly that we are a couple. And then you add two uh Hispanic girls next to them then you're like a walking struggle.
SPEAKER_00Wherever you go you're very much very much seen and and to me this was well this this this is us this is our family and we're claiming our space I have to say we claimed our space where we we went where that visible but you know it was important still is it still is you know wherever I go I mean I I talk about uh talk about you know uh being married having a husband and having kids one of them is away at college so and it I want to in a in in a way like when you say you know was it hard raising of course it was hard I mean it would be hard for anyone and there it was just the two of us it was just the two of us so we had to figure out parenting on on our own we don't have like parents or or siblings who could really help us it was just the two of us but I'm telling you uh we developed our network supportive network I would say primarily um they were what I call the strong moms strong moms in the neighborhood uh that that became our you know network of friends you know can you watch my child while I do this do you have an extra pair of diapers I mean all that sort of like you you know um and in that sense you know our household was no different than any other household you know uh from um from the you know taking care of them physically um um all the way through through their teenage years um to um yeah so I don't think it was really that much that much of a difference what I usually say is that it takes a responsible adult to raise a child it could be your grandparents it could be your great uncle it could be a gay couple it could be your birth parents but if there is that loving responsible adult you'll be given you'll be given the childhood that you truly deserve that's that that that's that's my point you know I would only add to that I was glad that we had those strong female friends yes you know those strong moms some are some were single some divorced some some married so our girls could actually uh grow up seeing them because you know they knew that they were loved they were taken care of they were all that but I wanted to see them as as a role models of what it takes to be a strong successful woman in this society today so in that sense I was glad they were exposed to that um and I believe that they they became who who I was hoping they would so that yes the village really really does help raise the kid absolutely yes it's no nobody does it alone but even if you don't have that you will develop it you will find it you will you will you will find you know life will bring you there yeah you'll create it okay question number three and this is shifting gears a little bit and I I want viewers to know I got permission from Lane ahead of time to ask this question. The questioner asks I am nervous about coming out to my parents I am not sure that they're going to take it well what should I do and so Lane I'm wondering if you can provide a little comfort a little inspiration to a young person who is a little nervous to come out to mom or dad or mom and dad or dad and dad or mom and well if it's dad or dad and mom and mom they'll probably be understanding but to mom and dad.
SPEAKER_02Right. Right well uh first of all um thank yourself you know for for being ready to do that it's it's a it's an important step and also something that will set you free in many ways knowing that you are fully living the life that that that that is yours that that that's intended for you um is is is extremely important. And I would say plan like any large decision in your life I think it takes it involves some planning. I would say look up resources um I would suggest um I did that um even though my parents kind of knew that I was gay anyway but but um I reached out to PFLAG even 25 years ago and I remember they they provided me there was a there was a book you know called Now That You Know which you're supposed to give to your parents I'm sure things might have gotten a little bit you know more more uh computerized instead of maybe not maybe that book's still there. So what what I did um I I prepared myself for it and I also kind of I I scheduled the time when I would be with each of my parents alone um you know uh I told my mom well I need to talk to her about something and let's meet at the coffee house and so we did and with my dad he lived near the campus where I was studying and I said hey you know I can we so um you have to be prepared that for for the for the unexpected for the unknown um my parents' reactions surprised me they were not what I expected they weren't negative that's not that but but they were just um I under I what I understood then that um first of all they they will need time to process that so don't expect things to to you know just for them to take take you know uh make an opinion about this right there right then for the rest of your life but no it's just if they need time to process the news and reconcile it s with what they know about you and that may take some time that's one scenario and another scenario um I've that I would say that even if they're negative it may pass. Time changes people change um and I would say sometimes they're just they just don't know you know so I I don't call it ignorance but just not knowing you know what it means to be someone that that's not like you um so it it it it takes time so so give give them space give them time to process what you tell them right and and don't take any any immediate re reaction that was super positive.
SPEAKER_01Oh wonderful I'm so happy that you're gay but you know I always dream I don't have a gay son or a gay mother or you know a transgender child.
SPEAKER_02Um well unless that happens just be ready that you may hear things that maybe not what you expected or maybe extremely negative and that's just the beginning it will take it the ultimately you're still their child and they're still your parents and and time will will will will work its magic.
SPEAKER_00Lane what a beautiful beautiful answer your first statement just has me in tears like the pride at them knowing that that's their life and that it's beautiful that they know that that's their life to live and just such sage advice to just give it time and not overreact to that first response. Thank you thank you thank you for sharing that with the viewer that needs to hear that so thank you.
SPEAKER_02Okay my fourth question is always ah makes me so feel so emotional for that kid sorry um okay good luck just yes I'll really pray for you yeah good luck kiddo okay sorry what is a piece of advice that you would like to share about anything that I have not asked you about tonight that you think that our viewers should know um well similar to what I said about um um preparing for coming out to your parents I would say that if you if you are considering uh foster adoption or or curious about it um just um expect the unexpected expect the unexpected because things may go every each way now what I told you that that we you know we we ended up with a kind of a long protracted story a lot of drama it may not happen you know we have friends who adopted painlessly I would say from the county but in some other school went through even worse situations than we did so it's unexpected but but learn about the system and arm yourself with resources and um I would say as a as a parent I learned not to project my expectations on my on my children because um I'm not them they're not me that took me a long time but I figured it out I figured out like just just let go of it and just try to understand the best who they are and how you know you should be there for them and support them in in their you know in in in what they need and and in in becoming the best they can be um you know um and another thing I would say is that another thing I learned through this experience is that the nucleus of our family is my relationship with my husband. Yes yes yes yes yes this is this is where where it starts because for the family to be stable that center has to be stable so take care of your partner love your partner uh give them more than they give you if you think but then notice that they're also giving you more than you give them so it's it's not about that just just just always keep an eye on your partner do not take your partner for granted partner for granted that's probably the other the adolescent oh those are all great pieces of advice Lane still together just to know we just celebrate our 29th anniversary hey congratulations that's so good that's wonderful that is wonderful Lane where can people find you if they want to read more about your story get your book watch more of your interviews etc Sure um I did publish a book called The Family Maybe um it's it's not in the second edition just came out the second edition just came out and it's a um it tell it tells you our story um it reads like a novel but it's not a novel it's actually just everything that happened there did happen. It's a it's a warm family building story and a core drama so that's what it is but I've been out with this book and and speaking about in many different places and you can look me up you can find the book on Amazon uh you can find bookshop.org uh barnes and noble uh you can also if you'd like me to sign it for you go to my website um and I will I you know I will sign it for you and mail it to you my website is laneeguddin.com l-a-n-e-i-g l-u-d-in- dot com or you can also uh find me and follow me on social media I'm quite active on Instagram and Facebook.
SPEAKER_00Okay awesome well we will link all of those in the show notes so that our viewers can find you Dr. Lane Igoden thank you so much for joining me on AdviceNight tonight. This has been amazing. I really appreciate your time and to all of the viewers I have two jobs for you number one I need you to hit that follow button so that you can be notified when new episodes come out and number two head over to advice.com and submit your questions remember it's anonymous so that I can answer it there or on my socials. You can look me up on Instagram YouTube Facebook and TikTok send those questions in so that I can get all up in your business. Okay Lane I seal every episode every social media post I seal every episode with a kiss so thank you again for being here and I hope you will join me yes and I hope you will join me with my kiss send off okay in three two one this is Stacy with AdviceNight and this is your reminder that I am not a doctor a lawyer or a therapist advice night is for entertainment purposes only and I certainly hope that you were entertained.